The McDuffie Mirror
  

Subscribe Today!
Quick Hits
    · Home
· Subscribe
· Contact Us
· Archive
· Subscribe
    · News
· Business
· Opinion
· Schools
    · Sports
    · Community
· Obituaries
· Weddings
· Engagements
· Births
· Anniversaries
· Submit Event

· Search Legal Ads


 E-mail this story      Printer-friendly version

Smoking ban to get more discussion

Frank Powell only spoke for five minutes, but his few words sparked a debate in McDuffie County. It's a debate that has already raged next door in Columbia and Richmond Counties.

Dr. Powell, a Thomson-based physician, asked the McDuffie County Commission to adopt a ban on smoking in public buildings during the Nov. 16 commission meeting. His speech was the culmination of a month of gathering momentum in favor of the ban.

"I would suggest that a great majority of the population is in favor of a smoking ban," Dr. Powell told commissioners.

During his speech, Dr. Powell explained that the sectioning of restaurants has been a failure in his view and that the status quo is putting non-smokers and children at risk for behavior they have no control over.

"We know that doesn't work," he said of having smoking and non-smoking sections in restaurants. "There's not a separation."

He also said the get-up-and-leave approach that has been suggested by those opposed to the ban is not viable for non-smokers when a smoker sits next to them. He asked, "What do I do when I'm not finished with my meal?"

Dr. Powell added that "Everyone in the health field is for this." He said it has become a public health issue and that it is time McDuffie County act to protect the health and well being of its citizens.

Commission Chairman Charlie Newton said the proposed ban would be discussed at the next work session on Nov. 29. He said if the other commissioners indicated they were willing to consider the proposal, public hearings would then be scheduled.

"I think folks here will be reasonable enough to entertain it," Mr. Newton told Dr. Powell during the meeting.

In lieu of a simple up or down vote, commissioners will discuss several options during the work session. One possible option is to have a partial ban, Mr. Newton said. Restaurant areas would be off limits for smokers, but a closed off bar area would still allow smoking.

Mr. Newton voiced his concern about the economic impact on businesses in the county. He said further research will need to be done to find out if a ban in other communities of similar size has negatively affected the food and beverage industry.

"I know there's a negative side to the smoke," Mr. Newton said, "but there may be a good compromise."

One compromise Dr. Powell suggested was to put the proposed ban to a public vote. Mr. Newton said an election would not be economically feasible as it would cost $10,000.

The issue could be tacked on to an already existing ballot at little extra cost, but the next county-wide election is two years away. Also, Mr. Newton fears that few would show up for a vote on a single issue.

Commission seeks public input
 • E-mail your comments for the McDuffie County Commission to smokingban@thomson-mcduffie.net

Documents
 • McDuffie County Smoke-free Air Act (.pdf)
(.pdf format requires Adobe Reader, click here for free download)

On the Net
 •  View public comments at Thomson-McDuffie.net

Previous stories
 • Smoking ban passes State House as McDuffie waits
 • County sets smoking hearing for Monday
 • Columbia ban begins; McDuffie considers same
 • Local business owners surveyed on prospect of smoking ban
 • Commissioners agree to public hearing on smoking ban
 • Smoking ban to get more discussion
 • Group plans to ask for ban on smoking

Poll
 • Should McDuffie County Commissioners approve a ban on smoking in public places in McDuffie County?

Opinion
 • Mind your butts and your community
 • Reasons Why
 • Smoking ban deserves commissioners' consideration
 • Smoke free is the way to be in McDuffie County

Your Say
 • Freedom to breathe freely

Letters to the Editor
 • Ban should be supported
 • Public health at root of ban
 • Time for smoking ban is now
 • Ban is about changing quality of lives for the better
 • Smoking ban push is a "great cause" to support
 • Ban would deter second-hand exposure
 • Protect the rights and health of people
 • Ban is about changing quality of lives for the better



Web posted on Thursday, November 18, 2004


What do you think?  Send us your comments










Weather
Temperature:53° F
Conditions:overcast
Wind:from the W at 5 MPH
Humidity:100%
Visibility:10 miles
Dew Point:53° F
Updated: 04-Nov-2010 10:01
Calendar
Thomson

Grovetown
42

14
Warren County

Wilkinson County
20

35
David Emanuel Academy

Briarwood Academy
12

22
· Scoreboard
Team Pages
Team Schedules

Calendar
February

S M T W T F S
21 22 23 24 25 26 27


Online Poll
Do you support the school system's graduation policy?
Yes
No
Undecided
View results











© 2011 The McDuffie Mirror. Contact the .
View our .